NRC, POGO, and Worker Fatigue

The NRC has proposed implementing one of the few POGO recommendations I agree with: reducing hours for security guards at nuclear power plants. I'd like to take this opportunity to draw a distinction between watchdogs and attack groups. We don't like to engage either, since neither tend to know what they're doing, and the NRC's unwillingness to admit anyone to discussions who isn't a member of the good ol' boy network doesn't help, but I submit that there is a difference that we need to be aware of.

We're used to being under attack; there hasn't been a moment in the last 40 years when we weren't. We are used to ignorant arguments coming from groups that are trying to shut down the industry, and accordingly have gotten used to taking any ignorant argument as a threat to shut down the industry. This, I believe, is a mistake.

Greenpeace and NIRS are attack groups. They have campaigns, use words like "shut" and "stop," and have a stated aim of trying to destroy nuclear technology. They cannot be reasoned with; they must be exposed as fools in public, their sources of volunteers and money cut off, and the loons in charge marginalized. We are familiar with them, their message, their strategy, and their tactics.

POGO, on the other hand, suffers from exactly the same problem as the industry and NRC: nuclear exceptionalism. They are a watchdog group; they believe that the NRC and government in general are not doing the best possible job and are trying to expose problems so they can be fixed. We disagree with them a lot, but they're not out to get us. They aren't the problem. Don't attack them in the manner that Greenpeace and NIRS attack the industry.

Joe Six-Pack thinks nuclear power plants pollute, are unsafe, and produce piles of leaking, deadly waste. They want a good reason to think that nuclear power plants don't do any of those things, and we can provide it--if we act graciously and professionally, and not wimpy or suburban, and destroy these urban myths with real information. As I've said before, people are not dumb--they just have other things to worry about. Tell me an auto mechanic can't understand how a nuclear power plant works.
The key is, they can't figure it out on their own. We have to do what every other technology proponent does, and provide information and involvement. Whatever you want to say about how it should be, the public is the boss.